Home Eat & Drink 9 Best Pizza Spots in Jersey City, NJ: Heights Classics, Desi Pies and More
Eat & Drink

9 Best Pizza Spots in Jersey City, NJ: Heights Classics, Desi Pies and More

Share
Pizzas, salads and small plates spread on a table at Porta on Newark Avenue in Jersey City, NJ
Photo: Porta / website
Share

Never miss what is happening in Hudson County

Events, new openings and weekend plans from Hoboken to Bayonne, Jersey City to Secaucus. Straight to your inbox, free.

Subscribe free

Jersey City pizza runs from a Heights pizzeria that has been tossing dough since 1959 to square bakery slices, Indian-spiced pies and star-shaped party pizzas. Our team picked 9 pizza spots across Jersey City, Hudson County, NJ, from Downtown to the Heights and Journal Square, and checked every address and menu detail on each shop’s own website.

Most of these spots offer pickup or delivery, so they work for a weeknight pie at home as well as a sit-down dinner with friends.

1. Renato’s Pizza Masters

Grandma pie from Renato's Pizza Masters on Central Avenue in Jersey City, NJ
(Photo: Renato’s Pizza Masters / website)

Renato’s has been serving the Heights since 1959. The family-owned pizzeria and restaurant is run by Richie DeMarchi and his sons, Mark and Lorenzo, and in 2017 it expanded across two storefronts on Central Avenue. The team calls its vodka sauce and Grandma pie, a thick, crispy rectangle with fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, olive oil and garlic, all-time favorites. There is a separate fine dining menu and catering too.

2. Paulie’s Brick House

A few doors down Central Avenue, Paulie’s puts its brick oven to work on pies named for Jersey City neighborhoods. The Heights is a classic Margherita, The Downtown is a white pie with arugula, prosciutto, truffle oil and a fried egg, and The Reservoir keeps it simple with tomato sauce, garlic and oregano and no cheese. Pies come in 12 and 16 inch sizes, with gluten-free and vegan options, and local 902 Brewery beer is on tap. Call (201) 434-1188.

3. Porta

Porta Jersey City opened in 2014 inside a former pharmacy just off the Newark Avenue pedestrian plaza, and it kept the pharmacy sign out front. The three-story restaurant has two full bars and one of the few rooftop spaces in the city, plus weekend brunch and live entertainment from DJ sessions to Showtune Sundays. The menu changes with the seasons, and this fall it includes a brick oven roasted acorn squash stuffed with house-made ricotta.

4. Prato Bakery

A baker brushing a square sheet of focaccia at Prato Bakery in Jersey City, NJ
(Photo: Prato Bakery / website)

Named for the Italian town of Prato, this bakery bakes its goods by hand every day. For pizza, grab a square of Pizza Margherita or Pizza Prosciutto di Parma alongside focaccia, then add a focaccia sandwich or an espresso. Prato has three Jersey City shops, on 4th Street, Bay Street and Palisade Avenue in the Heights.

  • Location: 371 4th Street (corner of Newark Avenue), Jersey City
  • More info: Prato Bakery

5. Lievito Pizza

Tomato sauce spread on fresh pizza dough at Lievito Pizza in Journal Square, Jersey City, NJ
(Photo: Lievito Pizza / website)

Lievito is Italian for what makes the dough rise, and this Journal Square shop makes both round pies and square pies, plus gluten-free choices. Specialty pies include a prosciutto pizza with arugula, goat cheese and Mike’s Hot Honey. Lievito also handles catering trays for offices and parties. Call (201) 918-6461.

  • Location: 584 Summit Avenue, Jersey City
  • More info: Lievito Pizza

6. Santa Maria’s Brick Oven Pizza

Santa Maria’s, also on Summit Avenue, pairs classic cheese slices and specialty pies with a Desi pizza menu: Chicken Tikka, Chicken 65, Paneer and Gobi pizzas. Calzones, strombolis, subs and gyros round out the menu.

7. VB3 (Villa Borghese III)

Pizza with roasted tomatoes, mozzarella and pesto from VB3 on Washington Boulevard in Jersey City, NJ
(Photo: VB3 Pizzeria / website)

On Washington Boulevard, VB3 pairs authentic Italian flavors with a modern twist. Try the Wild Mushroom pie with thyme and truffle, or the White pie with ricotta, roasted garlic, sea salt and fresh parsley. Gluten-free dishes are marked on the menu, and VB3 books holiday parties and catering. Call (201) 420-4823.

  • Location: 475 Washington Boulevard, Jersey City
  • More info: VB3

8. Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co.

Tino’s Warren Street shop is one of seven Tino’s locations in New Jersey. Its aim is home-style food made with fresh, all natural and organic ingredients, and it caters parties and events. Call (201) 433-6639.

9. Piscitelli Pizza & Pasta

Up on Kennedy Boulevard, Piscitelli is the place for a party pie: it makes star-shaped pizzas. Regular pies include a vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and prosciutto pie, and the menu also covers homemade lasagna, mussels marinara and hot sandwiches. Call (201) 903-2663.

More Ways to Eat in Jersey City

Hungry for more? See our picks for the best restaurants in Jersey City, or compare pies across the county in our best pizza in Hudson County guide. Planning a day out? Our guide to things to do in Jersey City has ideas.

Have a favorite Jersey City pizzeria? Vote for it in the Best of Hudson County 2026 ballot, and subscribe to our free newsletter for local food news every week.

Featured photo: Porta / website.

Have a Hudson County event coming up?

Share it with Hudson County.

Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Hudson County.

Share your event

Enjoying our Hudson County coverage?

Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.

Add as a preferred source
Share
Written by
Lisa Ganolli -

Lisa Ganolli loves exploring Hudson County, staying connected with everything happening in Jersey City and Hoboken, and discovering what makes the community special. She is passionate about supporting local businesses and highlighting the people, places, and events that make the area unique.

Shop Hudson County

Get Hudson County in your inbox

Weekend events, new openings, fall fun and hidden gems from all 12 Hudson County towns. Free, every week.

Subscribe free

Instagram  |  Facebook

Pawfect Journey: the 13 best automatic litter boxes of 2026
Related Articles
The brick Hudson and Manhattan Railroad Powerhouse with arched windows in Jersey City, NJ
Events

Save the Powerhouse Walking Tour in Jersey City Sat. Nov. 21: History Walk and Free Photo Talk

The Jersey City Landmarks Conservancy leads a Save the Powerhouse Walking Tour...

Fresh loaves of Italian bread at Leo's Bakery & Deli in North Bergen, NJ
Eat & Drink

7 Best Bakeries in North Bergen, NJ: Cuban Pastries, Chilean Kuchen, Italian Bread and More

Our picks for the best bakeries in North Bergen, NJ, from Fenix...

14th Street Garden Center on Jersey Avenue in Jersey City, NJ, decorated with wreaths
Shopping

Where to Buy a Christmas Tree in Hoboken and Jersey City 2026

Where to buy a Christmas tree in Hoboken and Jersey City 2026:...

Glass front and entrance of Liberty Science Center in Liberty State Park, Jersey City, NJ
Events

Winter Fest at Liberty Science Center in Jersey City Nov. 27 to Jan. 3: Sled Dogs, Santa and Sock Skating

Winter Fest returns to Liberty Science Center in Jersey City Nov. 27,...

Bacon pizza slice on a paper plate from Tom's Delicious Pizza in Union City, NJ
Eat & Drink

10 Best Pizza Spots in Union City, NJ: Brick Oven, Slices and More

Our team's picks for the best pizza in Union City, NJ, from...

The dining room at Las Palmas restaurant in West New York, NJ
Eat & Drink

8 Best Restaurants to Try in West New York, NJ

Cuban steakhouses, Colombian plates, Mexican tacos and vegan Latin-Asian fusion: our picks...

The bar at Urban Tandoor on Harrison Avenue in Harrison, NJ, with taps and shelves of spirits
Eat & Drink

10 Best Bars in Harrison, NJ: Pubs, Lounges and Game Day Spots

Our picks for 8 bars, pubs and lounges in Harrison, NJ, from...

Benny Tudino's pizzeria storefront on Washington Street in Hoboken, NJ
Eat & Drink

Best Pizza in Hoboken: 9 Pizzerias to Try

Best pizza Hoboken picks: Grimaldi's coal-fired pies, Benny Tudino's giant slices, Napoli's...