Best Pizza in Bayonne, NJ: 10 Local Pizzerias to Try

Bayonne takes its pizza seriously. Along Broadway, Avenue C and Kennedy Boulevard you will find a pizzeria that has been tossing dough since 1961, upside-down Sicilian squares, late-night slices and family dining rooms that have fed the same neighbors for decades. Our team at Shop Hudson County, NJ checked every spot below against its own website, so the addresses and details are current.

Here are 10 of the best pizza places in Bayonne, NJ for a quick slice, a family dinner or a party order.

1. Pompei Pizza

Pompei Pizza has been part of Bayonne since it opened in 1961. The menu runs from a simple Margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil to a Chicken Vodka and Fresh Mozzarella pie, and the pizzeria says its dough is made fresh daily.

• Location: 480 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-437-5408
• More info: Pompei Pizza

2. Pizza Masters

Pizza Masters calls itself a place where everyone is family. Choose from traditional, deep dish and Sicilian pies, then eat in, take out or order delivery. It is open every day from 11 a.m., with later hours on Fridays.

• Location: 532 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-437-4802
• More info: Pizza Masters

3. Joe’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

Joe’s is the late-night pick on this list. The pizzeria at the corner of 41st Street and Broadway stays open until 3 a.m. Monday through Saturday and until 1 a.m. on Sunday, and it caters events with 24 hours’ notice.

• Location: 876 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-437-6677
• More info: Joe’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

4. San Vito’s Restaurant and Pizzeria

San Vito’s pairs a long pizza menu, including Sicilian, white, buffalo chicken and seafood pies, with Italian dinners like Clams San Vito. It also caters, and it is open daily from 11 a.m.

• Location: 406 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-858-2448
• More info: San Vito’s Restaurant and Pizzeria

5. Mama Rosa’s Cucina and Pizzeria

Mama Rosa’s has served family recipes for over 25 years, and Theresa and her daughter Carmelina carry on the tradition today. Along with pizza, the restaurant takes reservations, hosts holiday parties and caters events.

• Location: 53 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-823-0500
• More info: Mama Rosa’s Cucina and Pizzeria

6. Mona Lisa Pizzeria Ristorante

Mona Lisa has been in business for more than 24 years and is famous for its specialty pizzas, especially the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Gluten free options are available, and its DaVinci Room hosts private events.

• Location: 165 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-858-1812
• More info: Mona Lisa Pizzeria Ristorante

7. Corner Square

Corner Square is the place for square pies. Its signature Brooklyn Special is an upside-down Sicilian with mozzarella on the bottom and sauce on top, and the menu also includes grandma pies, a hot honey pie with pepperoni cups and gluten free crusts.

• Location: 956 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-243-6304
• More info: Corner Square

8. La Guardiola Gourmet Pizzeria and Bistro

La Guardiola blends gourmet pizza with a bistro menu that includes entrees like baked flounder, blackened salmon over broccoli rabe and Zuppa di Pesce. It offers dine in, free delivery and catering.

• Location: 819 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-823-3399
• More info: La Guardiola Gourmet Pizzeria and Bistro

9. Fontana Pizza and Restaurant

Fontana is a neighborhood spot for hand-tossed pizzas, pasta, entrees and salads made with time-honored recipes. Stop in for a slice with friends or order takeout for a night in.

• Location: 1011 Broadway, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-823-4946
• More info: Fontana Pizza and Restaurant

10. Mike’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

Mike’s is the Avenue C option, serving pizza, pasta, sandwiches, salads and wings. It is open from noon daily and caters events of all sizes.

• Location: 474 Avenue C, Bayonne
• Phone: 201-437-9550
• More info: Mike’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

More Bayonne Food and Fun

Hungry for more? See our picks for the best restaurants in Bayonne, NJ, or compare these slices with our county-wide list of the best pizza in Hudson County. Walk it off afterward at Stephen R. Gregg Park.

Have a favorite Bayonne pizzeria? Vote for it in the Best of Hudson County 2026 awards, and subscribe to our free newsletter for local food news every week.

Featured image: Mona Lisa Pizzeria Ristorante on Broadway in Bayonne. Photo: Mona Lisa Pizzeria Ristorante / website.